The furnace came on this week, and the evenings got dark before dinner was ready. That is the stretch of the year when I pull the big pot off the top shelf and start making soup. This year I tried something a little different. I asked readers of this blog to tell me which soups and stews their families used to eat all the time and no longer make. The replies filled my inbox for days, and a lot of them sounded sad.
So I picked a soup or stew for each night of the week and cooked my way through the list. My husband came home to a steamy kitchen every evening. My three kids had opinions, and some of those opinions were loud. I am not sharing recipes here, since this blog moved away from recipes a while back. I am sharing what happened at our table, and what readers told me about their own tables.
Here is what I learned, pot by pot.
Beef and barley soup makes a small amount of meat enough for a family

My week of old soups started on a Monday with beef and barley. I pulled my mom’s card for it out of the recipe box, and the card was stained and soft at the edges. The soup used a small piece of beef, a handful of barley, and whatever vegetables were already in the crisper drawer. My husband went back to the stove for more without saying a word. Our youngest picked the barley out and lined it up on the placemat.
Ruth A., 71, of Erie, Pennsylvania, wrote to me about this soup. “My mother made beef and barley every Sunday in winter. Nobody in my family makes it now. The kids say barley is a texture problem.”
Barley is cheap and it swells in the pot, so a small amount of beef feeds everybody at the table.
Split pea soup with ham uses up the bone from a holiday dinner

On the Tuesday of my soup week, dinner was split pea soup with ham. The ham bone from a dinner weeks ago had been sitting in the freezer. I put the bone in the big pot with the dried peas and let the pot sit on low all afternoon. The house smelled like ham for hours. Our oldest walked in from school and asked what died. My husband loved the soup, said so at the table, and then said it again while loading the dishwasher.
Dale K., 63, of Dubuque, Iowa, told me about this soup. “We ate split pea the week after every Easter and every Christmas. My wife and I still do, but our kids throw the ham bone away.”
A ham bone in the freezer is the start of a cheap pot of soup, so do not toss it.
Navy bean soup needs a slow afternoon and feeds the house for days

Wednesday of my week of old soups was navy bean soup, and that was the day I learned the beans need to soak the night before. I forgot. So the pot sat on the stove most of the afternoon while I folded laundry and helped with homework at the kitchen table. The beans were ready right as my husband walked in the door. The leftovers fed us at lunch for the rest of the week, and my kids ate the reheated soup without complaint.
Marlene S., 58, of Topeka, Kansas, sent me this. “Bean soup was a Saturday thing in our house. It is cheap and filling, and I think people quit making it because it takes planning.”
Dried beans cost very little, and the planning is the only hard part.
Oyster stew gets made mostly because a holiday keeps it on the calendar

Thursday of my soup week was oyster stew, and I made it on a plain weeknight, which felt wrong to everybody at the table. My husband grew up eating oyster stew on Christmas Eve and said that exact bowl of milk, butter, and oysters showed up every year without fail. My kids would not touch the oysters. Our youngest asked if the oysters were alive. I ended up eating most of the pot myself over the next day, and I did not mind at all.
Howard P., 76, of Bangor, Maine, wrote to me about this stew. “My father made oyster stew every Christmas Eve. I keep the tradition up. My grown kids eat the crackers and leave the oysters in the bowl.”
Some old stews only get made because a holiday keeps them on the calendar, so protect the holiday.
Plain potato soup needs milk, butter, potatoes, and patience

Friday of my week of old soups was potato soup, the plain kind, with potatoes, onion, milk, and butter and nothing else. This was the soup my mom made when the pantry was almost empty at the end of the month. I stood at the stove stirring so the milk would not scorch, and that is the patience part. My husband put black pepper on his bowl until the top looked speckled. Our middle one said it tasted like thin mashed potatoes, and that was meant as a compliment.
Joyce W., 66, of Billings, Montana, sent me this. “Potato soup was what we ate when payday was far off. My daughter in law thinks it needs bacon and cheese and sour cream. We never had any of that.”
A plain potato soup is cheap and filling, and it is still good without any toppings.
Hamburger stew was dinner on the nights when money was tight

Saturday of my soup week was hamburger stew, which is ground beef, potatoes, carrots, and canned tomatoes in a pot. My husband said this was dinner most weeks growing up, and that nobody ever called it a recipe. I browned the meat while my kids argued over a board game in the next room. The stew was ready in less than an hour. Everybody at the table ate it, and nobody asked for ketchup, which at our house is rare.
Terry M., 54, of Flint, Michigan, wrote to me about this stew. “My mom called it poor man’s stew. We ate it so often I swore I never would again. Now I make it for my own kids and they love it.”
Ground beef and a few root vegetables make a stew that almost every kid will eat.
Cabbage soup smells up the whole house and feeds it anyway

Sunday closed out my week of old soups with cabbage soup, which is cabbage, sausage, and potatoes in a thin broth. The smell reached the upstairs within minutes, and our oldest came down to complain. My husband opened the kitchen window even though the air outside was cold. The soup itself was better than the smell promised, and my kids ate it with bread and butter. I understand now why people stopped making it. The smell is the reason, not the taste.
Anna D., 48, of Scranton, Pennsylvania, sent me this. “My grandmother made cabbage soup every week. I make it a few times a year because my husband hates the smell. The soup is wonderful. The house smells for a full day.”
Some old soups got dropped for the smell and not for the taste, so open a window and make them anyway.
By Sunday night the big pot had been washed and dried more often than it usually is in a month. My husband said the week felt like eating at a different house every evening. My kids asked which soup we were keeping, and the vote was split between the hamburger stew and the potato soup. I will keep a ham bone in the freezer and a bag of barley in the pantry from now on.
Most of these soups fell out of use because they take time, or planning, or because they smell, and not because they taste bad. Which old soup or stew did your family stop making, and would you bring it back?





