Fall dinner season is here. See our coziest fall dinners

Our hall closet door stopped closing in the middle of January. My husband pushed on it after work one night, and a bag of outgrown snow pants fell out onto the floor. We both stood there and looked at it. Nobody said anything for a minute. Then my husband said what we were both thinking. The whole house had gotten like that closet.

So we made a plan for the week. After my three kids were asleep each night, we would pick one kind of thing and deal with it. Not a whole room. Just one kind of thing. I used to be a teacher, and I know a big task gets done when you cut it into small steps. I also asked readers of this blog to tell me which things they find hardest to let go of. The answers lined up with my own list almost exactly.

Here are the six things that were the hardest for us that week, and what helped me finally let go of each one.

Keep the artwork that tells a story, not every page

A heartfelt child's drawing of their family, the kind of meaningful artwork worth keeping when decluttering.
Photo by olia danilevich on Pexels

The first night, my husband and I spread my kids’ school papers across the kitchen table. Three kids make a lot of paper. There were worksheets, drawings, and paintings that had stuck together in a bin. I picked up a crayon drawing of our family that our middle one made in preschool. I could not put it in the trash pile. Then I picked up a math worksheet with a sticker on it. I could not put that one in the trash either, and that was the problem.

My husband asked a simple question. He asked if I could say what each paper was about. For the family drawing, I could. For the worksheet, I could not. So we kept the ones with a story behind them and recycled the rest. One reader, Megan R., 44, of Columbus, Ohio, told me she takes a photo of the big projects and keeps the small drawings in a single folder per child. That is what I did too.

The takeaway is plain. Keep the pieces you can tell a story about, and let the rest go.

Baby things are easier to release when you choose where they go

A person sorts clothing into labeled keep, donate, and trash boxes while decluttering their home.
Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels

The second night was baby clothes. I had two big tubs of onesies, tiny socks, and a few blankets from when my three kids were small. I had told myself for years that I was saving them for somebody. I did not have a specific somebody in mind. That was the honest truth.

My husband pulled out a tiny striped sleeper and we both went quiet. I remembered our youngest wearing it. I knew I was not going to throw it away. So I made a different choice. I kept a few pieces that meant the most to me, enough to fit in one small box. Then I called a friend down the street who knows a family expecting a baby. The rest of the clothes went to that family the next day.

Giving the tubs to a real person made it much easier than putting them on a shelf for an imaginary one. The takeaway is simple. Decide where the baby things will go before you open the tub, and the letting go gets lighter.

A gift has done its job once it has been received

A child happily receives a gift, illustrating how once given and received, its purpose is fulfilled.
Photo by Helena Lopes on Pexels

The third night was the hardest one for me. We tackled the gifts. There was a decorative bowl from my mom that I had never used. There was a candle set from a coworker at my old school. There was a sweater from my husband’s side of the family that did not fit me and never had. I had kept every one of these things because somebody had picked them out for me.

My husband held up the bowl and asked if I liked it. I said no. He asked if my mom would ever ask about it. I said probably not. I realized I had been keeping the bowl so I would not feel guilty, not because the bowl made me happy.

A reader named Theresa K., 58, of Sacramento, California, wrote something that stuck with me. She said, “The love was in the giving. The object was just the wrapping.” I thought about that while I put the bowl in the donate box.

The takeaway is this. A gift has already done its job the moment you received it. You do not have to keep the object to keep the kindness.

Clothes that fit the life you have now are the ones worth keeping

Boxes labeled keep, donate, and trash filled with clothes being sorted during a decluttering session.
Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels

The fourth night, my husband and I pulled everything out of my closet and piled it on our bed. I found three pairs of jeans from before my kids were born. I found a blazer from my teaching days. I found a dress I bought for a wedding years ago and had worn one time. I had kept each of these for the same reason. I was waiting to be a certain size or a certain version of myself again.

My husband did not say much. He just asked me to try on the jeans. I did. They did not fit, and I knew they had not fit for a long time. Standing there in my bedroom, I felt tired of waiting for a body that was not coming back any time soon.

So I kept the clothes that fit the body I have and the life I live now. That means comfortable pants, warm sweaters, and shoes I can chase a kid in. The rest went into the donate box. The takeaway is plain. Dress the person you are today, not the person you were or might be someday.

Old work supplies belong to a chapter that is finished

A person carries a box of old work supplies, packing up a finished chapter of their career.
Photo by Anna Shvets on Pexels

The fifth night was my old teaching supplies. I used to teach before my three kids were born, and I had kept two boxes of classroom things in the basement. There were laminated posters, bins of markers, a grade book, and stacks of lesson plans in binders. Every time I opened those boxes, I felt like I was visiting an old friend.

My husband carried the boxes up to the kitchen. I went through the binders one at a time. Some of the lesson plans were good, and I was proud of them. But I had not looked at them in years. I am not in a classroom now. I am home with my kids, and that is the work I chose.

A reader, Diane M., 37, of Tulsa, Oklahoma, told me she donated her old nursing textbooks to a student and felt relief instead of loss. That gave me an idea. I kept one binder of my favorite lessons and gave the posters and markers to a teacher friend. The takeaway is this. You can honor a finished chapter without storing all of it in your basement.

Money already spent should not keep deciding what stays

Labeled keep, donate, and trash boxes filled with clothes, representing the process of deciding what stays and what goes rather than holding onto items just because money was spent on them.
Photo by RDNE Stock project on Pexels

On the last night, my husband and I went through the kitchen cabinets and the garage shelves for the expensive things we never use. There was a bread machine we used twice. There was a fancy coffee grinder still in its box. There was a treadmill in the garage with a coat hanging on it. Each of these things had cost real money, and that was the only reason any of them was still in our house.

My husband said the money was already gone. Keeping the bread machine did not bring it back. I knew he was right, but it still felt wrong to give away something that had cost so much. So we made a rule for ourselves. If we had not used it in the past year and could not name a day we would use it, it went.

The bread machine and the grinder went to a neighbor who bakes and loves coffee. We listed the treadmill for sale. The takeaway is simple. The money is spent either way. Keep the thing only if you actually use it.

By the end of the week, the hall closet door closed. My husband tested it twice to be sure. The donate boxes went out of the garage, and the house felt lighter in a way I could notice when I walked through it. My kids did not ask about a single thing that left. Not the baby clothes, not the artwork, not the bread machine.

I am still not finished. There are more closets and a shed, and I know the paper will pile up again by spring. But I learned that one kind of thing at a time, after bedtime, with my husband asking honest questions, works better than any big weekend purge I have tried before.

What is the one thing in your house you know you should let go of but have not yet?

About the author

Isabel Bernard
Isabel Bernard

Isabel is a stay at home mom of three, a former teacher and the home cook behind Sip Savor Mix. She shares the weeknight dinners, slow cooker meals and kitchen habits that… Read more

Scroll to Top