Fall dinner season is here. See our coziest fall dinners

The whole thing started with an email from a reader. A contractor had taken a deposit from her, done half the work, and then stopped answering calls. When she finally reached him, he was not sorry. He had a quick answer for everything. She asked me a simple question. Is there a way to tell early on that a person has no conscience?

I am not a counselor and I do not have a test for that. But I was a teacher before my kids were born, and I spent years listening to how people explain themselves. So I did what I usually do. I asked readers of this blog to send me the exact phrases that tipped them off. The replies came in fast.

For one week in late fall I sat at the kitchen table each night after my kids were asleep and read those replies. My husband got home after dinner most nights and read some of them over my shoulder. What surprised me was how ordinary the phrases were. Nothing dramatic. Just small sentences that showed up again and again from people who, in the end, hurt someone and did not care. Here is what readers sent me, along with the small moments from my own week that made each one land.

Blame always lands on someone else

A woman surrounded by accusing pointed fingers, symbolizing how blame is often shifted onto others.
Photo by Yan Krukau on Pexels

The first phrase readers sent me was some version of “That was not my fault.” Marla J., 44, from Fort Wayne, Indiana, wrote about a business partner who lost a large client through plain carelessness. “He said it was not his fault at least four separate ways in one conversation. The client was wrong, the assistant was wrong, the timing was wrong. He never once said the word sorry.”

That same night our middle one spilled a full glass of milk and said the cup was slippery. I laughed, because that is what a child does. Then I thought about Marla’s partner. A grown adult doing the same thing is not funny.

Everyone slips up. A person who cannot admit a single mistake is showing you something about how much they value other people.

Everyone does it is a cover, not a reason

A woman shrugs defensively, as if making excuses rather than owning up to her actions.
Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Pexels

The next reply I read at the kitchen table that week was about the phrase “Everyone does it.” Greg P., 61, from Tacoma, Washington, sent a story about a coworker who padded expense reports for years. “When he got caught, he was not embarrassed. He said everyone does it and he just got unlucky. He actually seemed annoyed at the rest of us for not doing it too.”

I remember hearing a version of this from students when I was teaching. A kid caught copying homework would say the whole class did it. The point of the sentence was never to describe the class. The point was to make the wrong thing feel normal.

When a person reaches for what everyone else does, they are usually trying to avoid looking at what they did.

Your feelings become the problem instead of their actions

A woman looks visibly upset and pulls away while the man beside her seems indifferent, reaching toward her as if deflecting blame onto her reaction instead of his actions.
Photo by Keira Burton on Pexels

Several readers sent me the phrase “You are too sensitive.” Tina H., 37, from Little Rock, Arkansas, wrote about a former friend who made cutting remarks at every gathering. “Any time I brought it up, she said I was too sensitive and needed to toughen up. I spent two years thinking I was the problem. Then I noticed she said the same thing to every single person who pushed back.”

I read that one out loud to my husband while he was putting dishes away. He stopped and said that is a neat trick, because now nobody can ever complain. That is exactly it. The sentence moves the whole conversation away from what was said and onto how the other person reacted.

A person with a working conscience hears that someone was hurt and gets curious. A person without one hears it and gets defensive.

Memory gets rewritten whenever it is convenient

A man scratches his head with a doubtful look, as if his memory of the truth is conveniently fuzzy.
Photo by Pavel Danilyuk on Pexels

A lot of replies mentioned the phrase “I never said that.” Lorraine B., 49, from Mobile, Alabama, wrote about a sister who promised to help pay for their mother’s care and then flatly denied the promise months later. “I had the text messages. She looked right at them and said I was twisting her words. It was not that she forgot. She just decided the past was different now.”

That one stayed with me. During the week, our oldest and our youngest argued about who had agreed to feed the dog. They are kids, so they really did forget. But Lorraine’s sister had the messages in front of her. There is a difference between forgetting and refusing.

When someone rewrites a conversation to suit themselves, and does it calmly, pay attention. That is not a memory problem.

Every favor comes with a question about what they get

Two business associates shake hands over paperwork, hinting at a favor that comes with hidden expectations.
Photo by Ron Lach on Pexels

One of the shorter phrases readers sent was “What is in it for me?” Devin M., 33, from Des Moines, Iowa, described a roommate who would not pick up a prescription for him when he was sick with the flu. “He asked what he would get out of it. Not as a joke. He wanted to know what I would do for him in return before he would drive ten minutes.”

My husband came home that evening and brought in the neighbor’s trash cans along with ours because the wind had knocked them over. He did not mention it. I only noticed because I saw the cans lined up. That is the opposite of asking what is in it for you.

Some people only do kind things when there is a return on them. Over time, that tells you how they see other people.

Other people’s trouble is never their concern

Two women stand apart with arms crossed, each looking away indifferently, ignoring each other's presence.
Photo by Liza Summer on Pexels

The phrase “That is not my problem” came up in more replies than I expected. One reader, who asked me not to use a name, wrote about a landlord who left a broken furnace unfixed for most of a winter. “I told him my kids were sleeping in coats. He said that was not his problem, the lease said repairs happen on his schedule. He was not angry. He just did not care.”

I thought about that while I was folding laundry during the week. There are plenty of things that are not technically my job. A neighbor’s sick kid is not my job. A friend’s bad week is not my job. But I would never say so out loud, because the sentence itself is a way of closing a door.

A person who says other people’s hardship is not their problem is telling you how they will treat you when you need something.

A joke is the easiest place to hide a cruel remark

Two coworkers laugh at a joke while another colleague sits visibly hurt and overwhelmed at his desk.
Photo by Yan Krukau on Pexels

Many readers sent the phrase “I was just joking.” It usually came right after something unkind. Marla J. from Fort Wayne, the same reader who wrote about her business partner, added a second note. “He would insult people in meetings and then say he was joking when the room went quiet. The joke was never funny. It was just a way to say the thing and then take it back.”

Our oldest tried this at dinner during the week, with a comment to our middle one about a drawing. When I said that was not kind, the answer was “I was kidding.” We talked about it. A joke that only one person laughs at is not a joke to the other person.

When someone uses humor as an exit after every hurtful remark, the humor is not the point. The hurt is.

Kindness becomes a debt you are expected to repay

One person handing cash to another, symbolizing a transactional exchange reminiscent of keeping score in relationships.
Photo by Berna on Pexels

The phrase “You owe me” showed up often, and it bothered me the most. Greg P. from Tacoma wrote a second note after his first one. “This same coworker kept a running list in his head. If he covered a shift for you once, he brought it up for years. Nothing he did was free. He was collecting.”

That week my mom called to ask if I needed anything from the store, because she knew my husband was working late. I said no, and she brought over a bag of apples anyway. There was no tally. There never has been. That is what help looks like when it comes from someone who cares.

A person who keeps a ledger of every favor does not actually give favors. They make loans.

Secrecy is the only rule they respect

A man with a serious, judging look silently signals for secrecy with a finger over his lips.
Photo by Andrea Piacquadio on Pexels

A few readers sent the phrase “No one will ever know.” Tina H. from Little Rock added a second story to her first. “A guy I dated for a while returned a used appliance to the store and told them it was defective. When I said that was not honest, he said no one would ever know. That was his whole moral code. If no one finds out, it is fine.”

I read that reply to my husband, and he said something I wrote down. He said the real test of a person is what they do when nothing would happen either way. The appliance was a small thing. But a person who only behaves when watched will not stay small.

If someone measures right and wrong by whether they will get caught, the rules in their head are not about right and wrong at all.

Honesty is used as a shield for meanness

A woman angrily confronts someone, hands raised, illustrating how blunt words can mask cruelty disguised as honesty.
Photo by Liza Summer on Pexels

The last phrase readers sent me was “I am just being honest.” Lorraine B. from Mobile, who wrote about her sister, sent one more reply. “My sister said this constantly. Every harsh thing about my weight, my husband, my house, was just her being honest. But she was never honest about herself. The honesty only ever pointed outward.”

I thought about that while I was packing lunches at the end of the week. I try to be honest with my kids. But honesty, the real kind, costs the person saying it something. It is uncomfortable to admit you were wrong. It is easy to say something harsh and call it truth.

When a person is only ever honest about other people’s flaws, that is not honesty. It is cruelty with a nicer name.

By the end of that week, the pile of printed replies on my kitchen table was thick, and the pattern was plain. None of these phrases are rare. I have probably said a few of them myself on a bad day. The difference is what comes after. A person with a conscience hears themselves, feels the sting, and corrects it. A person without one says the same sentence again next week, and the week after that.

I wrote back to the reader who first emailed me about the contractor. I told her the phrases are not proof of anything on their own. But if someone uses most of them, calmly, and never seems to notice who they hurt, that is worth paying attention to. Which of these phrases have you heard from someone who turned out to be exactly who they sounded like?

About the author

Isabel Bernard
Isabel Bernard

Isabel is a stay at home mom of three, a former teacher and the home cook behind Sip Savor Mix. She shares the weeknight dinners, slow cooker meals and kitchen habits that… Read more

Scroll to Top